Skip to main content



Rocks, stupas, straw heaps, and elephants

On my way back from the University of New Mexico, after three weeks of reading Kumārila's upamāna-pariccheda (the "comparison chapter" of the Ślokavārttika) with John Taber, I experienced what Kumārila calls upamānâbhāsa, or "pseudo-comparison" or "merely apparent comparison."
But where a cognition of similarity arises, having imagined it from what is not really similar, the cognition of similarity in such cases is something imagined, having the nature of a mere appearance (40).
And because the [similarity cognition] is subject to a defeater cognition (bādaka), it is considered to be a merely apparent similarity, just as the similarity of a straw heap with an elephant or so on (41).
For someone standing in close proximity discerns that there is no similarity there [in the straw heap]. That [similarity cognition] which is not defeated when there are such things as close proximity, that, in contrast, is genuine similarity (42).yatra tv asadṛśād eva kalpa…

Latest Posts

Advice for new graduate students in Indian philosophy

Teaching debate and reasoning with Nyāya

The Daily Naiyāyika?

Book Blogging: Three Pillars of Indian Skepticism, Conclusion